Mica - Opposing view TSA: Expand federal-private model


By John Mica
When Congress established the Transportation Security Administration after 9/11, I helped craft airline passenger screening provisions.

OUR VIEW: Don't privatize, don't unionize

ANOTHER OPPOSING VIEW: Screeners deserve more rights

Two models of screening were established. The principle model established an all-federal TSA screening force. The second model provided that TSA would certify, regulate and oversee private contractors to perform screening functions.

Initially five airports — one in each size category — were selected for the federal-private model. Those chosen and operating successfully since 2002 are San Francisco; Kansas City, Mo.; Rochester, N.Y.; Jackson Hole, Wyo.; and Tupelo, Miss.

The Government Accountability Office independently conducted performance evaluations of both models. GAO's initial evaluations found that the federal-private model performed statistically significantly better than the all-federal model. Subsequent evaluations have shown the federal-private model performing consistently as well as the all-federal model.

Two years following the 2001 law's enactment, all airports were permitted to apply to opt out of all-federal screening. Under this option, airports qualified by TSA can also take over screening functions, as Jackson Hole has done.

Sixteen airports currently operate successfully under the federal-private model. More airports have submitted applications, and others are considering opting out.

While TSA has argued the federal-private model costs more, the agency did not properly account for private-sector cost efficiencies, federal retirement costs, taxes paid by private companies, at least partial elimination of a huge bureaucracy and more.

TSA has grown from a pre-9/11 force of 16,500 screeners, that then lacked proper federal regulation or oversight, into a massive, growing force of 62,000. TSA's bureaucracy includes more than 3,500 administrative personnel in Washington and 7,000 supervisory employees throughout the nation.

It would be far better for a streamlined TSA to focus on setting and checking security standards and auditing performance, rather than spending much of its time, resources and energy on managing a huge ballooning bureaucracy.


Join AFGE Today

BECOME A MEMBER

Vote 2018

Weekend of Action

Fight Back the EOs

AFGE Events

Event Calendar is for Members Only. Please Log In to see our calendar of events.

LOG IN!

SUBSCRIBE Latest news & info